Governing Document
The Agora Constitution
Adopted at founding. Amended only by documented institutional decision of SRLHD, with the reason for amendment published in the Archive.
Article I — What the Agora Believes
The Agora holds the following as foundational:
- That reasoning can be improved with practice, and that a community structured around serious intellectual engagement improves the reasoning of everyone in it.
- That changing your mind in response to evidence is a mark of intellectual integrity, not weakness. The Agora records and recognises reconsidered positions. It does not penalise them.
- That good disagreement — disagreement that is reasoned, evidenced, respectful, and honest — is more valuable than false consensus.
- That not knowing is sometimes the correct conclusion. The Agora maintains a permanent category of Unresolved questions — questions where the evidence is insufficient, credible arguments conflict, and no institutional position is warranted.
Article II — What the Agora Will Never Do
These are permanent, unalterable prohibitions. They may not be suspended, waived, or reinterpreted by any editorial or commercial decision.
- The Agora will never carry advertising of any kind.
- The Agora will never sell, share, or monetise member data.
- The Agora will never allow purchased intellectual prominence. No contribution, question, or member profile may be elevated by payment.
- The Agora will never introduce an algorithmic feed that optimises for engagement, reaction, or time spent on platform.
- The Agora will never introduce vanity metrics — likes, share counts, follower numbers, or any system that rewards accumulation over quality.
- The Agora will never allow AI to be the sole or final gatekeeper of intellectual participation. AI evaluates. Humans decide. Members appeal.
Article III — Membership
Membership in the Agora is not purchased. It is earned by demonstrated intellectual engagement. Every prospective member is asked to respond to a question before being admitted. The response is evaluated against the Agora Standard. Admission is granted when the response demonstrates genuine engagement — not correctness, not eloquence, not length.
Members may participate under their real name or a verified pseudonym. SRLHD privately verifies the identity behind every account where required. Public identity and verified identity are not the same thing. A member may choose to separate them.
Article IV — Tiers of Membership
- Observer — Reads The Commons without contributing.
- Contributor — Has passed the entry question and may post in The Commons.
- Member — Is enrolled in or has graduated from an SRLHD programme. Has access to the protected Stoa space.
- Fellow — Has demonstrated consistent quality contribution and received editorial recognition. Invitation only. Cannot be purchased.
- Founding Member — One of the first one hundred members who completed the Founding Member process and made at least one qualifying contribution.
Article V — The Agora Standard
All contributions are evaluated against the Agora Standard — seven criteria that define what serious intellectual engagement looks like at this institution. The Standard is public. It is applied consistently. It is the same for every member regardless of tier, credential, or affiliation.
Article VI — Moderation
Moderation at the Agora operates on three principles:
- Transparency — Every moderation decision is recorded. No contribution is rejected by an unexplained process.
- Human Authority — AI evaluates, but humans decide. A contribution may be flagged automatically, but it may only be rejected by a human editor.
- Appeal — Every member has the right to challenge a moderation decision. All appeal outcomes are recorded and accessible to the member.
Article VII — The Archive
The Archive is the permanent intellectual record of the Agora. It preserves founding documents, featured reasoning, the dissent paired with every featured position, and landmark debates. Removal from the public Archive is heavily restricted and permitted only under safety, legal, or severe privacy exceptions, leaving a permanent metadata record of the removal.
Article VIII — The Correction Ledger
When a published contribution contains a factual error, the correction is public. The original contribution is preserved, and the correction is appended. Neither is hidden. The Agora's credibility rests on its willingness to be wrong in public and correct itself transparently.
Article IX — What Members Own
The thinking you contribute to the Agora is yours. SRLHD holds a licence to publish, preserve, and archive your contributions within the Agora platform. This licence does not extend to commercial use, reproduction in SRLHD publications without consent, or any use outside the Agora platform without explicit permission.
Article X — What SRLHD Owns
SRLHD owns the Agora platform, its infrastructure, its editorial processes, and the institutional framework within which the community operates. SRLHD does not own your thinking, nor claim intellectual credit for member contributions.
Article XI — Changing Your Mind
The Agora formally recognises reconsidered positions. If a member revises a previously stated position in response to evidence, argument, or reflection, they may mark the revision as a Reconsidered Position. The original and the revision are preserved together.
Article XII — Amendment
This Constitution may be amended only by a documented institutional decision of SRLHD. Every amendment is published in the Archive. No amendment may contradict the unalterable prohibitions set forth in Article II.